Growing Butterhead lettuce

Lactuca sativa var. capitata butter lettuce, Boston lettuce, Bibb lettuce
Other names
Butter lettuce, Boston lettuce, Bibb lettuce
Botanical name
Lactuca sativa var. capitata
Family / Genus
Asteraceae / Lactuca
Plant category
Leaf Salad
Butterhead lettuceSmileus/Shutterstock.com

A garden without your own fresh lettuce is only half a garden. You can sow butterhead lettuce, like the other garden lettuces, straight into the bed or raise it in modules first. In spring it pays to start plants off indoors, in summer direct sowing works better. The plants then grow much longer roots, reach water more easily and are slower to bolt, which means they don't run to flower and turn bitter so quickly.

Butterhead lettuce, also called round lettuce or, in Austria, Häuptlsalat, is a form of garden lettuce. Its stem is heavily compressed, so the leaves sit close together and form the rounded head.

Facts and figures

Light requirements
Sun / partial shade
Nutrient requirements
Medium feeder
Difficulty level
Easy
Culture (according to Gertrud Franck)
C - low growth, short growing period
Culture (according to Sister C. Weinrich)
Companion crop
Frost resistance
Semi-hardy to -10 °C
Growing period
70 - 225 days
Row spacing
30 cm
Plant spacing
30 cm
Growth height
20 - 30 cm
Sowing depth
1 cm
Germination temperature (minimum)
3 °C
Germination temperature (optimal)
15 - 18 °C
Germination type
Light
Pre-growing period
35 days

Planting & harvest times of Butterhead lettuce

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
Direct sowing
Pre-grow
Transplant
Harvest
Harvest (next year)

SummerDirect sowing from Mid March to Mid August. Transplant to bed from Mid March to Late August. Pre-grow about 35 days before transplanting, approximately between Mid February and Mid July. After a growing period of 80 days, harvest can begin around Early May and continues until Late October.

GreenhouseDirect sowing from Late January to Late February. Transplant to bed from Late February to Late March. Pre-grow about 35 days before transplanting, approximately between Mid January and Mid February. After a growing period of 70 days, harvest can begin around Early April and continues until Mid May.

WinterDirect sowing from Early September to Mid September. Transplant to bed from Late September to Mid October. Pre-grow about 35 days before transplanting, approximately between Mid August and Early September. After a growing period of 225 days, harvest can begin around Mid April and continues until Mid May next year.

Winter 2Transplant to bed from Mid October to Early November. Pre-grow about 35 days before transplanting, approximately between Early September and Late September. After a growing period of 170 days, harvest can begin around Late February and continues until Late March next year.

Sow and plant Butterhead lettuce

Winter: Shows overwintering outdoors

Winter 2: Shows overwintering in an unheated greenhouse

In most regions you can sow lettuce straight into the bed from around late March. In spring, though, it pays to start it off indoors, because that lets you begin a month earlier, from late February. At the start of April you plant out the first lettuces. Harden them off first: get them used to sun and outdoor temperatures bit by bit by putting them outside for a little longer each day over several days. When planting, set the lettuces slightly higher than they sat in the pot, otherwise they can rot from the base.

In most regions you can sow lettuce straight into the bed from around late March. In spring, though, it pays to start it off indoors, because that lets you begin a month earlier, from late February. At the start of April you plant out the first lettuces. Harden them off first: get them used to sun and outdoor temperatures bit by bit by putting them outside for a little longer each day over several days. When planting, set the lettuces slightly higher than they sat in the pot, otherwise they can rot from the base.

Lettuce needs light to germinate, so only cover the seeds with a very thin layer of soil. Above 20 degrees it germinates poorly, so sow summer batches in the evening, give them some shade or let the tray pre-germinate somewhere cool. Outdoors, plant at 30 x 30 cm, as heads that stand closer together rot more easily. If you want to harvest into autumn, sow again every two weeks until early August. To overwinter outdoors, sow winter varieties in early to mid September and plant them in shallow drills at the beginning of October.

Location and soil

Lettuce needs a sunny spot, though in high summer some light shade is fine. In spring and autumn it prefers full sun. It is fairly undemanding and grows in most soils, as long as they aren't too acidic. A steady water supply matters, but it can't cope with waterlogging.

Good and bad companions of Butterhead lettuce

Lettuce is the classic gap filler in the veg bed. It has shallow roots, stays low and is ready to cut after a few weeks, so it fits between almost any crop that starts slowly: young cabbages, kohlrabi, leeks, tomatoes, peppers, cucumbers, climbing beans, sweetcorn or strawberries. By the time the neighbours need the space, you've long since eaten the lettuce. Gertrud Franck mixed radishes or winter radishes into every row of lettuce, as the lettuce is said to keep flea beetles away, and Sister Christa Weinrich plants it next to kohlrabi for the same reason. Carrots and lettuce get on well too: mix one part lettuce seed with four parts carrot seed, and the lettuce is gone before the carrots spread out.

Good row companions are spinach, beetroot, Swiss chard, peas and dwarf French beans. Sister Weinrich even sows the beans in May straight between the standing heads. Chervil sown in the lettuce row is said to deter aphids and slugs and keep the lettuce tender, and dill and borage along the edge also count as good partners.

Parsley shouldn't go right next to lettuce, as the lettuce is said to stay small or die beside it. The same goes for garden cress, which makes lettuce bolt. Many charts list celery as a bad neighbour, but Gertrud Franck grew the two side by side without trouble, and there's no evidence of any harm.

Very good neighbours
Black radish
Radish
Radish
Good neighbours
Asparagus
Aubergine
Basil
Beetroot
Black salsify
Borage
Broad bean
Broccoli
Brussels sprouts
Bush bean
Cape gooseberry
Caraway
Cardoon
Carrot
Cauliflower
Cavolo nero
Chervil
Chilli
Chinese cabbage
Chives
Coriander
Cucumber
Dill
Endive
Fennel
Flower Sprouts
Garlic
Garlic chives
Globe artichoke
Honeydew melon
Kale
Kohlrabi
Leek
Lupin
Maize
Marigold (Tagetes)
May turnip
Melothria
Mizuna (Asian Greens)
New Zealand Spinach
Onion
Orache
Pak choi
Parsnip
Pea
Pointed cabbage
Pole bean
Pot marigold
Radicchio
Red cabbage
Rhubarb
Rocket
Romanesco
Runner bean
Salsify
Savoy cabbage
Shallot
Spinach
Spring onion
Strawberry
Subterranean clover
Sugarloaf chicory
Summer savory
Swede
Sweet pepper
Swiss chard
Tarragon
Tomatillo
Tomato
Tree onion
White cabbage
Neutral neighbours
Celeriac
Celery
Cutting celery
Bad neighbours
Chamomile
Garden cress
Hamburg parsley
Parsley
Potato

Predecessors and successors of Butterhead lettuce

Butterhead, lollo, oak leaf, iceberg, Batavia and cos lettuces all belong to the same species. For crop rotation they count as one single lettuce, and endive, radicchio, sugarloaf chicory and witloof chicory join them as members of the daisy family. Leave three years between them, otherwise soil fungi such as Sclerotinia rot and the lettuce root aphid build up in the bed. Wait three years after sunflowers as well, because they multiply Sclerotinia rot particularly strongly.

Good preceding crops for lettuce are leeks, onions, garlic, spinach, courgettes and early Florence fennel, which leave a clean, loose bed. After cabbage and other brassicas, lettuce grows less well the following year, and after potatoes wireworms go for the young plants. Beans, peas, cucumbers, parsley and celery share Sclerotinia rot or the soil fungus Rhizoctonia with lettuce, so commercial growers treat them as risky preceding crops. In a home garden with a sound rotation, lettuce usually grows after them without problems, and many mixed-planting plans even put it straight after early peas. If you've ever had rotting heads in the bed, though, leave a gap of two to three years.

As a first crop, lettuce is worth its weight in gold: in the same year you can follow it with cucumbers, tomatoes, aubergines, cabbage, Swiss chard, beetroot or New Zealand spinach, and with alliums the year after. Better not to plant beans straight after lettuce, as both share Sclerotinia rot, whose resting bodies survive in the soil for years.

Good predecessors
Black radish
Carrot
Chervil
Common vetch
Courgette
Fennel
Garlic
Kohlrabi
Leek
Oats
Onion
Radish
Radish
Shallot
Spinach
Spring onion
Winter rye
Neutral predecessors
Bush bean
Celeriac
Celery
Cucumber
Cutting celery
Hamburg parsley
Parsley
Pea
Pole bean
Runner bean
Bad predecessors
Batavia lettuce
Borage
Broccoli
Brussels sprouts
Butterhead lettuce
Cardoon
Cauliflower
Cavolo nero
Chicory
Chinese cabbage
Cos lettuce
Endive
Flower Sprouts
Garden cress
Globe artichoke
Iceberg lettuce
Jerusalem artichoke
Kale
Lollo bionda / Lollo rosso
May turnip
Mizuna (Asian Greens)
Mustard
Oak leaf lettuce
Oil radish
Pak choi
Pointed cabbage
Potato
Radicchio
Red cabbage
Rocket
Romanesco
Savoy cabbage
Sugarloaf chicory
Sunflower
Swede
White cabbage
Winter cress
Good successors
Aubergine
Beetroot
Broccoli
Brussels sprouts
Cauliflower
Cavolo nero
Chilli
Chinese cabbage
Courgette
Cucumber
Flower Sprouts
Honeydew melon
Kale
Kohlrabi
Melothria
New Zealand Spinach
Onion
Orache
Pointed cabbage
Red cabbage
Romanesco
Savoy cabbage
Sweet pepper
Swiss chard
Tomato
Watermelon
White cabbage
Neutral successors
Carrot
Bad successors
Batavia lettuce
Bush bean
Butterhead lettuce
Cardoon
Chamomile
Chicory
Cos lettuce
Endive
Globe artichoke
Iceberg lettuce
Jerusalem artichoke
Lollo bionda / Lollo rosso
Oak leaf lettuce
Pole bean
Pot marigold
Radicchio
Runner bean
Sugarloaf chicory
Sunflower

Varieties

Read the variety descriptions carefully. Some are only suitable for spring growing, others for summer, and some manage both. A few varieties are suited to overwintering. In summer, especially when it's very hot, other garden lettuces often do better. Batavia and cos lettuces, for example, handle summer heat better. The old winter varieties such as Winterkönig, Neusiedler Gelber Winter, Winterbutterkopf or Brauner Winter survive the winter outdoors and give you the first heads at the end of April. Aphid-resistant varieties save you a lot of trouble in spring.

Care and fertilising

Keep lettuce evenly moist, but not wet. Under drought stress the leaves turn tough, and the plant can run to flower and become bitter.

Lettuce doesn't need fertiliser, but a layer of compost on the bed in spring or autumn does no harm. Don't plant it in heavily fed beds either, as lettuce can then build up nitrate.

Fresh manure encourages rot, so keep it off the lettuce bed. Loosen the soil after heavy rain and mulch thinly in summer. In winters without snow, cover winter lettuce with a few brushwood twigs. In an unheated greenhouse, water it only every four to six weeks on a sunny morning and ventilate well.

Diseases and pests

In a home garden lettuce is usually a healthy crop, and its worst enemies are slugs and snails. They strip seedlings and freshly planted lettuces overnight, and later they hide in the outer leaves. Plant sturdy young plants into a bed you've left open for a few days, collect slugs in the evening and keep the soil around the lettuce loose. We've had good results with slug collars.

Aphids like to sit in the hearts of the heads, especially in the greenhouse in spring. They spread lettuce mosaic virus, which mottles the leaves yellow-green and stunts the plants. Aphid-resistant varieties, insect mesh and healthy seed help most. If a lettuce suddenly wilts even though the soil is moist, lettuce root aphid is often at the roots. Then only a change of site and resistant varieties will help.

In late summer and autumn, downy mildew shows up as yellow patches on the older leaves with a white coating underneath. Use resistant varieties for late sowings or switch to endive. In wet weather, heads rot from below: grey mould, Sclerotinia rot and Rhizoctonia bottom rot all start from the soil. Plant lettuce high enough that half the root ball shows, water in the morning, don't use fresh manure and leave three years between lettuce crops.

After potatoes or freshly dug-up grassland, wireworms gnaw at the roots, and the plants wilt and die within days. Lay out halved potatoes as bait two weeks before planting and use only well-rooted young plants. Cutworms bite through young plants at the base of the stem. Sturdy young plants and a net help here too.

Susceptible to
Bacterial leaf spot of lettuce
Bacterial soft rot
Corky root rot
Cucumber mosaic virus
Currant-lettuce aphid(resistant varieties available)
Cutworms
Green peach aphid
Grey mould
Lettuce anthracnose
Lettuce big vein
Lettuce downy mildew(high susceptibility, resistant varieties available)
Lettuce mosaic virus(resistant varieties available)
Lettuce root aphid(resistant varieties available)
Mycocentrospora rot
Northern root-knot nematode(high susceptibility)
Pollen beetle(low susceptibility)
Powdery mildew of the daisy family(low susceptibility)
Pythium root rot
Rhizoctonia
Silver Y moth
Slugs(high susceptibility)
Tomato spotted wilt virus
Vegetable leaf miners
White mould
Wireworm(high susceptibility)
Not a host for
Stem nematode

Harvest and processing

Once the lettuce looks good, you can cut it. The harvest window for butterhead lettuce is short: for about five days the head is firm and sweet, then it stretches and the leaves turn tough and bitter. Harvest early in the morning, wash and spin the lettuce and keep it in a damp cloth in the fridge, where it lasts two to three days. If more lettuce is ready than you can eat, cut halfway through the stem and the head will bolt a few days later. Heads cut in spring often push out a few small leaves again from the stump.

Open the bed planner Try free for 7 days, web, iOS and Android